The Percentile Percent Chance

I doubt I’m the first person to ever come up with this mechanic, but I can’t remember ever seeing it anywhere else. Anyway, I’ll just throw it out there…

This is a simple tool I use sometimes when a PC asks if something is available or nearby; something that very well could be, and could be useful if it were, but not something I had given any thought to. A good example would be asking if there is a payphone, data terminal, or a what-have-you nearby in a modern or cyberpunk style setting, or maybe a particular flower or herb in a wilderness setting. Of course you could simply say yes or no and move on, but sometimes the presence of such a thing could make a real impact in the way events play out and simply saying yes or no on a whim often doesn’t seem “fair.” This is where the Percentile Percent Chance comes in. I simply roll percentile dice, out in the open, and whatever number is rolled becomes the percent chance that the asked about item is in the immediate vicinity. The player then rolls percentile dice, attempting to roll equal to or less than whatever the percent chance is.  And that’s it! I roll two dice, they roll two dice, and we’re back in the action.

Of course, you can get more involved with it if you want, maybe adding or subtracting a flat percentage from whatever the die roll is to represent the presence of the object being more or less likely (that plant does grow in this region, but it’s rare, etc.). I would make this sort of adjustment sparingly though, otherwise you might as well just say yes or no.

You may also be thinking “Why not just make an herbalism or an urban knowledge check?” I would say that if the situation is such that the character has the time to search for something then sure, go ahead and use a relevant skill, or just say they find it. I use this mechanic when the need is immediate (I need to jack in now! Is there a terminal nearby?) and the presence or absence of the object/thing in question is both plausible and could affect the story in an interesting way.

3 thoughts on “The Percentile Percent Chance

  1. Unfortunately with this kind of roll, you end up with a ~50.3% chance of success, regardless of what was rolled the first time.

    Here’s some empirical data I collected (wrote a program to simulate the rolls 10000 times):

    values: {False: 4957, True: 5043}
    values: {False: 4980, True: 5020}
    values: {False: 4934, True: 5066}
    values: {False: 4936, True: 5064}

    That’s four separate runs of the program, for a total of 40000 d% followed by d% rolls. True indicates success by the player, False indicates failure. By these results, you’re better off flipping a coin.

    Neat mechanic, but the math bungles it out of use 😦 I was going to use it for something similar myself, but wanted to run the math on it before I used it.

    (program is here, if you’re interested and know python:

    1. Having about a 50% chance of success sounds like it is exactly what this mechanic is designed to hit over a long enough period of time (Either that payphone is there, or it isn’t). I still think it’s better and more exciting to make the rolls in the heat of the moment than just arbitrarily saying yes or know, or even flipping a coin. Interesting to see how the math works out on this though, thanks for the effort!

      1. Oh, I agree. There’s something to be said about giving the players a feel of power in determining their own fate.

        Heck, you could add a layer of mystery by making the GM roll hidden, and just letting the players know whether or not it’s there after their roll. That could increase tension without tweaking the odds. Now, just don’t let your players see this article :p

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s